A comprehensive documentary titled "History PROVES Catholicism" argues that historical evidence validates the tenets of the Catholic Church over those of Protestantism and Eastern Orthodoxy. The nearly nine-hour film systematically explores various theological and historical topics to build its case for the continuity and authority of the Catholic faith from the first century to the present day.
The documentary is a collaborative effort between the YouTube channels @MilitantThomist and @UnionistInitiative. It is structured into several key sections, each addressing a specific area of theological debate.
The film begins by instructing viewers on how to interpret the writings of the early Church Fathers, asserting that their works support Catholic doctrines. It then delves into the development of dogma and the historical basis for the papacy, examining the Meletian Schism and the question of a heretical pope. The documentary also defends the actions of Pope Zosimus and argues against scriptural interpretations that challenge papal authority.
A significant portion of the documentary is dedicated to the "Filioque" clause, a major point of contention between the Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches. The filmmakers present arguments from the Cappadocian Fathers, St. Thomas Aquinas, and St. John of Damascus to support the Catholic position. They also critique what they term as "innovations" within Eastern Orthodoxy.
Further sections of the film defend the Catholic understanding of the Trinity and Christology, addressing and refuting opposing views. The documentary also mounts a critique of Protestantism, claiming that it has "destroyed the New Testament" and misrepresented Marian doctrines. It also presents historical evidence for the belief in Purgatory dating back to the 5th century and defends the Catholic Mass.
Later in the film, topics such as double predestination, Molinism, and a historical perspective on Vatican II are discussed. The documentary concludes with a discussion on the theological figure Origen. The creators note that while the film aims to bring all people into the Body of Christ, the opinions expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily the official position of the Catholic Church.