Already good advise above.
i would lean towards Princess since we did not have a bad experience on our Alaska cruise several years ago. Last summer we took them on a Mediterranean cruise with just positive experiences. I would not feel too obligated to use their "shore excursions". For our last one, we basically used Viator and booked private excursions to see many of the same places with a similar costs, but no crowds. If you like to gamble, the on-boat casinos were decent.
My uncle who is close to your age did his first cruise on Princess (also to Alaska) last year and since then has done a couple of others (all Princess).
Someone asked about Disney...We were on on one when the kids were younger to the Caribbean during the 2008 downturn. Was an a great experience at that age for their (and my) first cruise. They had a rebound offer to go back for a few hundred dollars and all of us ended up taking adult friends. Most of the boat did too and it was a totally different experience since it became almost adult only (felt kind of sorry for the few families on board)..
i would lean towards Princess since we did not have a bad experience on our Alaska cruise several years ago. Last summer we took them on a Mediterranean cruise with just positive experiences. I would not feel too obligated to use their "shore excursions". For our last one, we basically used Viator and booked private excursions to see many of the same places with a similar costs, but no crowds. If you like to gamble, the on-boat casinos were decent.
My uncle who is close to your age did his first cruise on Princess (also to Alaska) last year and since then has done a couple of others (all Princess).
Someone asked about Disney...We were on on one when the kids were younger to the Caribbean during the 2008 downturn. Was an a great experience at that age for their (and my) first cruise. They had a rebound offer to go back for a few hundred dollars and all of us ended up taking adult friends. Most of the boat did too and it was a totally different experience since it became almost adult only (felt kind of sorry for the few families on board)..