Zombie Jon Snow said:
FtWorthHorn said:
I watched last night. I think the biggest problem is that in trying to create an interesting story with ambiguity (to stress how difficult the decision-making would be), they forced a nonsensical situation. If there are 200 missiles coming, there's not much drama it's just the end of the world.
So you make it one missile with an unknown origin and create drama that way. The problem is the answer in that situation is obvious - just wait and work out what happened. And the US nuclear forces were perfectly safe from that one missile, so the time pressure was nonsensical.
I get why they made these decisions, but ultimately it comes out as kind of a mess.
You also send more than 2 interceptor missiles.... because about a 30% success ratio means 2 is not enough. Only one of the two successfully even separated the kill vehicle from the booster rocket and then they said those have a 60% success ratio. Thats 30% it seems. It was dumb to send two and cross your fingers.
You do everything to bring down that one missile.
They even tried to make the case for saving the rest back (stating that they had 50 interceptors in case of a bigger attack). But if you play the situation out the way they did and intend to launch in any way against someone or multiple countries to try to knock them out first, then their response is to send thousands of missiles our way in which case 50 interceptor missiles mean nothing. You expend 6, or 8 or 10 to try to bring that thing down.
I honestly would love to see a movie along the lines of this one, but with a mentally incompetent, borderline braindead president, who has no clue where he is half of the time, can barely form complete sentences, and relies on illegal use of the auto-pen to get things done.
Can you imagine how incredibly entertaining and also frightening a movie like this would be with a walking vegetable directly in charge of the nuclear football? Imagine a scene where he's casually licking ice cream and just trying to stay awake while command conducts emergency meetings with an ICBM en route to hit America within the next hour. Holy smokes.
Imagine his deviant crackhead son in there like "THESE MF'ERS! (sniff sniff) DAD WE GOTTA HIT THESE MF'ers (sniff), WE GOTTA MAKE EM PAYYY MANNNN! F*** THIS SH** DAD WAKE THE F*** UP MANN NN!"
Would be entirely too realistic and disturbing maybe.