Ranking Aggie QBs over the last twenty years.

Criteria: must have started at least one game. Judging them on A&M tenure not how they played elsewhere ex: Murray winning the Heisman at OU…

Johnny Manziel (obviously)

Stephen McGee (Tough as Nails. Willed us to victory in some tough games.)

Ryan Tannehill (maybe the most talented pure QB)

Jerod Johnson (Great Aggie. Efficient when not injured.
Should have sat out his last year to fully heal)

Kellen Mond (Durable and pretty efficient)

Marcel Reed (Jury still largely out. Shows flashes.)

Trevor Knight (Superman incarnate. Was pretty mid as a passer)

Dustin Long (didn't get a fair shake - was better than Reggie at playing QB.)

Max Johnson (hard to tell - seems injury prone)

Kenny Hill (started strong, then fluttered)

Kyle Allen (Mostly forgettable. Threw a pretty long ball)

Connor Weigman (for whatever reason just didn't work out)

Reggie McNeal (Fran ruined him.)

Zach Calzada (Beat Bama)

Kyler Murray (Just remember him being very small)

Jake Hubenak (He might have been good if given more of a shot)

Jaylen Henderson (not enough film to say otherwise)

Haynes King (injury bug)

Nick Starkel (injury)

So... I guess you went back and figured it out.

I disagree

Looking at Kyle Allen, Reggie McNeal and Conner grouping, talk about wasting 5* talent. I think Murray was more of helicopter dad, Kevin Murray, not getting his way.

Quote:

---

Jake Hubenak (He might have been good if given more of a shot)

---

wasnt he a walk on only playing because of transfers and injuries?

AggieNattie said:

---

Watch Weigman light it up at UH and maybe become a dark horse heisman candidate. Another Kyler Murray scenario. Bet the farm on it. We waste talent like no other at A&M.

---

I saw a few photos of him in practice. U of H ha managed to get him in shape.

RingOfive said:

---

Dustin Long above Reggie? You're insane.

---

Dustin Long, a Texas A&M quarterback from 2001-2003, threw for 3,218 yards and 23 touchdowns during his career. He notably had a record-breaking sophomore season, including a game where he threw for a then-record 399 yards against Kansas. He also tied the school record for most touchdowns in a season with 19 and set a Big 12 record with 7 touchdown passes in a single game against Texas Tech.

lol trevor knight was "superman incarnate"? was i just too drunk to remember knight being anything other than forgettable?

Mort Rainey said:

---

McGee at 2 is ridiculous

---

Seamaster obviously has some bias. McGee and Long both ranked too high. Weigman as well.

It is sad that Johnny is really the only one that consistently elevated the team.

It is also really hard to rank them because of the different offenses, and different supporting talent they had around them.

King of the Dairy Queen said:

---

lol trevor knight was "superman incarnate"? was i just too drunk to remember knight being anything other than forgettable?

---

I don't think he was Superman but he had us rolling pretty good. If he doesn't get hurt at MSU I think we do enough to win and we would also beat Ole Miss.

That's 10-2 regular season with a chance for 11 wins.
We would have been 2nd in West and 3rd overall in SEC.

Playing in the Sugar Bowl probably.

He would be viewed a lot differently.
But if my aunt had balls….

AggieNattie said:

---

Watch Weigman light it up at UH and maybe become a dark horse heisman candidate. Another Kyler Murray scenario. Bet the farm on it. We waste talent like no other at A&M.

---

The Fishpond Manager is dating a gal from Cougar High. She says Coach laid down the Ban Hammer on ALL Magicians. CW has a chance!

Gam.
So.

AggieNattie said:

---

Watch Weigman light it up at UH and maybe become a dark horse heisman candidate. Another Kyler Murray scenario. Bet the farm on it. We waste talent like no other at A&M.

---

Lol. Not our fault Weigman sucked at A&M. Kyler Murray was just a freshman so totally different.

1, Johnny Manziel
2. Stephen McGee
3. Reggie McNeal
4. Kellen Mond
5. Ryan Tannehill
6. Mark Farris
7. Jerrod Johnson
8. Kenny Hill
9. Nick Calzado
10. Trevor Knight
11. (tie) others

Long shouldn't even be on the list. He falls outside the OP's 20 year window. 2001-03.

Calzada had an out of body experience 1 game and beat Bama.
Outside of that, Calzada was terrible

Max Johnson

Zach Calzada

Jake Hubenak

Haynes King

Nick Starkel


legends, all of them

He is Ass My Dude said:

---

AggieNattie said:

---

Watch Weigman light it up at UH and maybe become a dark horse heisman candidate. Another Kyler Murray scenario. Bet the farm on it. We waste talent like no other at A&M.

---

I saw a few photos of him in practice. U of H ha managed to get him in shape.

---

Maybe he's off the ganja?

1. Manziel
2. McNeal( falls in because of senior year of 2005)
3. J Johnson
4. McGee
5. Mond
6. Tannehill
7. Knight
8. Allen
9. M Johnson
10. Hill

Hard to find a top ten. Lots of incompletes too with guys like King and Murray. Reed can vault into the top 5 pretty easily with a solid season

OldFox61 said:

---

1, Johnny Manziel
2. Stephen McGee
3. Reggie McNeal
4. Kellen Mond
5. Ryan Tannehill
6. Mark Farris
7. Jerrod Johnson
8. Kenny Hill
9. Nick Calzado
10. Trevor Knight
11. (tie) others

---

Jerrod Johnson is the most overrated player in these type discussions.

He was ok... then he got hurt and was mediocre after? Ok, but that's how his career played out.

Also, flip Tannehill ahead of Mond. Mond got the most opportunities of anybody on here. If he was more talented, we may have won a national championship his senior year.

Long far ahead of freaking Jerrod Johnson.

Other thought- we didn't have a bad run of qbs overall there. Just shows how we are underachiever U. Having Mond only get hurt for ONE play ever (which ended up being a pick v. Clemson)- over 4 years- burned a lot of time A&M really could have been good.

Manziel
Mond
Reggie
Tannehill
McGee
JJ

Who cares about the rest.