cena05 said:
Did you leave out this quote or am I reading it wrong?
"Anderson remains steadfast in his blunt messagenamely, that we have to face these authoritarian *******s with all the fight that we have. "
Cliff.Booth said:Quote:
And everything boils down to a few simple things. Firstly, how easily are you propagandized?
Second, was this your type of propaganda?
Or lastly, are you confident enough to admit that this is propaganda when all of the institutional hack critics look you directly in your eyes and tell you that this is one of the greatest films ever made.Quote:
This is more of the same far-left pandering we've been getting from Hollywood for years. There's just one caveat here. It's wrapped in competent film making that's undercut with a very busy story and an odd comedy element that works together to disarm the viewer. This all allows those who enjoy this to excuse their propaganda and gaslight you, the viewer, into thinking it's some sort of balanced, intelligent commentary.
An authority who emanates and inspires love; not an authoritarian of fear or ideology or paranoia.
— The Civilian (@mrleonardclass) September 30, 2025
The key line is when Sensei tells Bob during the police raid, "We've been doing this for hundreds of years." He's telling Bob welcome to the fight, it's Ok, we know how to handle this.
— urban myths, legends (@urbanmyths) September 30, 2025
Even the little kids know how to get on the radios and warn the community when bad things are…
feels like a lot of ppl missed this & focused on the literal "firework show" that is the french 75 instead
— Tom Ato ੯‧̀͡⬮ (@TomAtoForReal) September 30, 2025
its a giant play pen for them - perfidia's adrenaline/sexual high off it, bob's search of meaning & ego stroking [+battle of algiers idolization], junglepussy's bank show
TCTTS said:
Again, I realize just how much some of you can't stand these "woke" themes in general, no matter how innocuous. That said, all I keep seeing are takes like the below, where basically everyone and their dog realizes that the French 75 are meant to be depicted in a negative/ineffective light. Yes, the movie is pro "don't treat illegal immigrants like ****," but what the movie is definitively NOT endorsing or romanticizing is violent ideology/extremism. This fact really is just plain as day now.
The last tweet is especially on point, underlining how it's not really about "the revolution" for any of the French 75. For Perfidia, it's more about the adrenaline/sexual high she gets from it, for Jungle***** it's the showy, attention-***** performance of it all, etc. In other words, "violent extremism" is simply a means to quench each of their shallow/selfish kinks and desires. It's what THEY get from it, not what society gets from it.
Bob, on the other hand, is the only one who eventually sees their bull**** for what it is and, at the end of act one, chooses something real instead: his daughter/family. One would think that conservatives could get behind such a positive message, but because there's still a tinge of "woke" to the whole thing I guess it's no-can-do for a handful of you.An authority who emanates and inspires love; not an authoritarian of fear or ideology or paranoia.
— The Civilian (@mrleonardclass) September 30, 2025The key line is when Sensei tells Bob during the police raid, "We've been doing this for hundreds of years." He's telling Bob welcome to the fight, it's Ok, we know how to handle this.
— urban myths, legends (@urbanmyths) September 30, 2025
Even the little kids know how to get on the radios and warn the community when bad things are…feels like a lot of ppl missed this & focused on the literal "firework show" that is the french 75 instead
— Tom Ato ੯‧̀͡⬮ (@TomAtoForReal) September 30, 2025
its a giant play pen for them - perfidia's adrenaline/sexual high off it, bob's search of meaning & ego stroking [+battle of algiers idolization], junglepussy's bank show
TCTTS said:
The thought of going through life this way, and making these kinds of decisions based solely on this kind of criteria, will never not be so hilariously sad and performative to me. Outside of TexAgs, even back in Texas, among all my conservative friends and family, I never, ever hear people talk this way.
Especially considering damn near everyone agrees that, regardless of its politics, this is an entertaining, incredibly well-made movie. Hell, the audience score on Rotten Tomatoes is 85%, never mind the 96% critics score or the near-unanimous praise in this thread alone. But because some random YouTube chodes "confirm" (hahaha) that it's "leftist propaganda," the movie is suddenly "trash" you must announce to all of us that you're going to skip.
Good Lord, this place is never not so ****ing weird.
Quo Vadis? said:TCTTS said:
Again, I realize just how much some of you can't stand these "woke" themes in general, no matter how innocuous. That said, all I keep seeing are takes like the below, where basically everyone and their dog realizes that the French 75 are meant to be depicted in a negative/ineffective light. Yes, the movie is pro "don't treat illegal immigrants like ****," but what the movie is definitively NOT endorsing or romanticizing is violent ideology/extremism. This fact really is just plain as day now.
The last tweet is especially on point, underlining how it's not really about "the revolution" for any of the French 75. For Perfidia, it's more about the adrenaline/sexual high she gets from it, for Jungle***** it's the showy, attention-***** performance of it all, etc. In other words, "violent extremism" is simply a means to quench each of their shallow/selfish kinks and desires. It's what THEY get from it, not what society gets from it.
Bob, on the other hand, is the only one who eventually sees their bull**** for what it is and, at the end of act one, chooses something real instead: his daughter/family. One would think that conservatives could get behind such a positive message, but because there's still a tinge of "woke" to the whole thing I guess it's no-can-do for a handful of you.An authority who emanates and inspires love; not an authoritarian of fear or ideology or paranoia.
— The Civilian (@mrleonardclass) September 30, 2025The key line is when Sensei tells Bob during the police raid, "We've been doing this for hundreds of years." He's telling Bob welcome to the fight, it's Ok, we know how to handle this.
— urban myths, legends (@urbanmyths) September 30, 2025
Even the little kids know how to get on the radios and warn the community when bad things are…feels like a lot of ppl missed this & focused on the literal "firework show" that is the french 75 instead
— Tom Ato ੯‧̀͡⬮ (@TomAtoForReal) September 30, 2025
its a giant play pen for them - perfidia's adrenaline/sexual high off it, bob's search of meaning & ego stroking [+battle of algiers idolization], junglepussy's bank show
Indeed just a tinge of woke. I definitely go to transflag X accounts for a balanced interpretation of what is and what isn't left wing propaganda.
Also, the movie is definitely endorsing revolutionary violence, and condoning attacks on ICE/Border Patrol/Anyone to the right of Rashida Tlaib
If you think conservatives are going to watch 2.5 hours of Antifa porn only to get behind the "pothead decides to support daughter's ostensibly left wing activism after a life time of violence" you might want to actually meet a few conservatives
TCTTS said:Quo Vadis? said:TCTTS said:
Again, I realize just how much some of you can't stand these "woke" themes in general, no matter how innocuous. That said, all I keep seeing are takes like the below, where basically everyone and their dog realizes that the French 75 are meant to be depicted in a negative/ineffective light. Yes, the movie is pro "don't treat illegal immigrants like ****," but what the movie is definitively NOT endorsing or romanticizing is violent ideology/extremism. This fact really is just plain as day now.
The last tweet is especially on point, underlining how it's not really about "the revolution" for any of the French 75. For Perfidia, it's more about the adrenaline/sexual high she gets from it, for Jungle***** it's the showy, attention-***** performance of it all, etc. In other words, "violent extremism" is simply a means to quench each of their shallow/selfish kinks and desires. It's what THEY get from it, not what society gets from it.
Bob, on the other hand, is the only one who eventually sees their bull**** for what it is and, at the end of act one, chooses something real instead: his daughter/family. One would think that conservatives could get behind such a positive message, but because there's still a tinge of "woke" to the whole thing I guess it's no-can-do for a handful of you.An authority who emanates and inspires love; not an authoritarian of fear or ideology or paranoia.
— The Civilian (@mrleonardclass) September 30, 2025The key line is when Sensei tells Bob during the police raid, "We've been doing this for hundreds of years." He's telling Bob welcome to the fight, it's Ok, we know how to handle this.
— urban myths, legends (@urbanmyths) September 30, 2025
Even the little kids know how to get on the radios and warn the community when bad things are…feels like a lot of ppl missed this & focused on the literal "firework show" that is the french 75 instead
— Tom Ato ੯‧̀͡⬮ (@TomAtoForReal) September 30, 2025
its a giant play pen for them - perfidia's adrenaline/sexual high off it, bob's search of meaning & ego stroking [+battle of algiers idolization], junglepussy's bank show
Indeed just a tinge of woke. I definitely go to transflag X accounts for a balanced interpretation of what is and what isn't left wing propaganda.
Also, the movie is definitely endorsing revolutionary violence, and condoning attacks on ICE/Border Patrol/Anyone to the right of Rashida Tlaib
If you think conservatives are going to watch 2.5 hours of Antifa porn only to get behind the "pothead decides to support daughter's ostensibly left wing activism after a life time of violence" you might want to actually meet a few conservatives
It's truly amazing how y'all can keep repeating this line over and over and over again without addressing a single, direct argument I've made to the contrary. Not one of you has actually engaged with the substance of my posts, refuted the dozens of receipts I've brought, or attempted to seriously try and dispel my specific narrative/screenwriting points. Don't you find it suspect that literally all y'all can manage is the exact same company line, repeated ad nauseam, without providing any additional evidence whatsoever in response to the specifics I've offered? Otherwise, y'all've done nothing but lob Nuh-uhs and LOLs and flat-out dismissal of well-reasoned substance simply because it came from a lib account. To that end, you'll mock the person posting but you won't even address the argument itself? That right there tells me everything I need to know. Every post of y'all's is full of bluster and mocking, but then… absolutely nothing else. Just "It's revolutionary violence propaganda!" without the hows and the whys contrary to the countless specifics I've offered in return.
Sea Speed said:
TC, do you think it's possible that any/some/a significant portion of the viewing population will view this movie as glorifying violence towards right wing authoritarians and/or ICE and the like?
Cliff.Booth said:
Good analysis of the numbers despite a click-baity title. Dicaprio doesn't disappoint, his acting in this is strong, it's just a movie Americans aren't in the mood to watch because it's demonizing good people and glorifying bad people.
Cliff.Booth said:
You put too much stock into how much anyone will care about that. She put her passion for the revolution (terrorism) over her desire to be a Mommy yada yada yada. The whole film is an underground resistance movement fighting fascists who want to enforce immigration control, and, lo and behold, they're all just the nicest, coolest people. It's propaganda.
TCTTS said:Cliff.Booth said:
You put too much stock into how much anyone will care about that. She put her passion for the revolution (terrorism) over her desire to be a Mommy yada yada yada. The whole film is an underground resistance movement fighting fascists who want to enforce immigration control, and, lo and behold, they're all just the nicest, coolest people. It's propaganda.
So, yeah, you can still think the movie is "woke" for that messaging, but it's still CLEALY disavowing the VIOLENT brand of resisting in the first act.
“One Battle After Another” is about a young hero with a secret-but-evil father drawn into an unlikely desert adventure against fascists that brings a washed-up robe-wearing revolutionary out of exile joining a rebellion.
— Darren Mooney (@Darren_Mooney) September 29, 2025
It’s basically a “Star Wars” film, is what I’m saying. pic.twitter.com/1kH8bm9tEv
Cliff.Booth said:
I don't scope out F16 very often. I still think youve just lived in LA now for over half of your life and lost touch with normal red state people. The people you talk down on on here are probably good Ags and good people, you just hate dissenting opinions.
BadMoonRisin said:
Does anyone else think that the trailer was just bad?
I couldn't really tell what the movie was about and the juxtaposition between the unrealistic looking pregnant woman shooting an automatic weapon next to "Steve Lockjaw just invaded my home" made it look like some sort of parody.