I watched it over the weekend and I really enjoyed season 4. Season 4 felt like fan service in a lot of ways but I needed some fan service TBH. I think the show is at it's best when it can balance stress and trauma with heart and humor. To me the show got a bit heavy on the stress and trauma and was just off balance, for my own personal enjoyment anyway.Troy91 said:You hit on something here. For those of us who watched the Feast of Seven Fishes and had childhood flashbacks, this show hits us in a very deep spot.AJ02 said:
I guess I'm weird, bc I loved season 4. Yeah, it was introspective and dialogue heavy, but it all resonated deeply with me. The background and struggles of the various characters....it felt like the writer had lived my life for a lot of it. I was blown away by the little things that the writers picked up on. Stuff that probably didn't even register for most people who didn't experience a childhood like Carmey had. Like Lee when he was just about to say "you should go visit your mom", and he stopped just short. And Carmey later thanked him for not saying it. That hit deep for me.
Growing up amidst the chaos, you just find something to focus on and some way to get praise outside of the home. Unfortunately, that also comes with a heavy dose of self destructive behavior.
Viewing the series through that lens, it is less about a restaurant and more about Carmine trying to build a family. Seeing success happen amidst the chaos is simply normal to him. He doesn't know calm or measured anything. Season 4 was more of that and it won't resonate with everyone as a result.
I know for some people the wedding episode fell flat for a number of reasons and I actually really liked it. The thing that didn't work for me was casting Brie Larson as Francine, she does not fit with the cast and definitely not as a member of the Fak family. I thought the scene under the table was sweet, and this show needs moments like that to balance itself out. The more I think about it the more the scene with Carmy and Lee stays with me. When Lee reveals that he and Mikey eventually became friends it was clear that Carmy has a problem processing that. He couldn't process Mikey being able to bury the hatchet after what went down at Christmas, because he wouldn't be able to and he probably never forgave Lee for that argument with Mikey.
At first I really disliked the last episode. I couldn't put my finger on it but for me I couldn't make sense of Carmy doing what he did. I think his decision was ultimately related to the fact that he's not only been hiding from processing Mikey's death and he's basically been trying to recreate him in the restaurant with the people around him but he can't do it. He can't bring back Mikey regardless of how hard he works. He also doesn't need to do anything for Mikey, Mikey was already proud of him. He never came to terms with losing the person who kept him grounded to the earth. I still think the last episode needed work but at the same time Carmy is a mess so maybe it makes sense that the episode is messy.
I hope they do season 5. I think they can wrap this thing up nicely, I'm not ready to be done with this show.