Who is Israel?

18,452 Views | 307 Replies | Last: 2 mo ago by Zobel
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wish I had more time for this thread…..marking it, so we will see.

"anti-Semitic" is a major personal trigger.

What a weaponized, garbage phrase.

Wilhelm Marr has left quite an unfortunate legacy
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We need to define terms. In detail. Especially when it so greatly serves one side to keep it ambiguous. Very good for shutting down debate, isn't it?
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This is e-litigated about once a year.

As a proud Semitic son of Aleppo, here's some background reading.

I will define terms in detail. Will those who are not Apostolic (Catholic / Orthodox) do so? Let's demand it.
More soon

Who is a Jew?
https://texags.com/forums/15/topics/3266062/last#last

Related,
https://texags.com/forums/15/topics/3413229

My background
https://texags.com/forums/15/topics/3166505
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
All Israel is a reference to the combination of Ephraim (the northern kingdom of Israel) and Judah.

At the time of St Paul's writing there was no more Israel. It had been gone for centuries. Only Judah remained, and the Judahites or Judaeans. People who practiced the religion and customs (the nomos) of the people of Judaea were called Judaeans, and this way of life was called Judaismos. In other words, those people were Jews because they lived by Judaism.

Judah is a subset of All Israel.

When St Paul says ALL Israel will be saved he means not only the Judaeans, but also the other ten tribes that were completely lost and gone by his time. The prophets said all of those tribes would be saved - like Ezekiel in the dry bones prophecy. It's a recurring theme in the prophets. Not just Judah, but Ephraim also.

The northern kingdom was lost into the nations, to the gentiles - scattered into them like seed. So when the gentiles come to faithfulness to Jesus, to Yahweh, they are reconstituting the lost tribes, bringing them back to life, resurrecting them like Ezekiel's vision of the dry bones. The two sticks become one, Ephraim and Judah.

There is only one tree, Israel. Some branches were cut off. The gentiles are grafted in, resurrecting those tribes. Other branches may be cut off, and may be grafted in again as well.

The chosen people of God are those attached to the single Tree, which is Israel. The Church is the Israel of God. The gentiles are what make it All Israel.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The people Israel are those that follow the Logos of John 1, who has appeared many times, including in the Old Testament.

Since 33, we have known Him, God with us, as Jesus Christ.

Abraham and all of the great figures of the OT worshipped the Triune God.

Logos and anti-Logos, this is the central divide of the world.

Christianity is older than Judaism, which was fully reconstituted by grave necessity when Titus absolutely decimated, running the streets with blood, exactly as Our Lord predicted. Mark Antony's military headquarters are all that now stands.

The victory of Jesus Christ was total. Judeans that accepted Him? Christians. Exactly like the Greeks, and all others. When the chief rabbi of Rome, Israel Zolli, became a Catholic in 1949, a man from a very distinguished line of rabbis….now we are one in Christ!

The Temple is our body, the Eucharist our holy Sacrifice.

I hope all Jews join in the peace of Christ, and leave the churn of anti-Logos, the chief defining characteristic of "Judaism" since 70 AD.
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
one MEEN Ag said:

There is a lot of to unpack here. Got to back way way up.

There are three tiers of nations in the OT in the era of Abraham/Isaac/Jacob.
-Israel
-Other Abrahamic people groups descendant from Abraham (Like the Edomites descendant from Esau)
-The table of nations that describe the rest of the known world and are pagan. These are gentiles.


Fast forward 1900 years. The modern nation of Israel has no ties or prophecies left to the physical land or nation of Israel. They are LARPing under the name of Israel. The Scofield bible did an absolute number on evangelicals getting those purposefully confused. Modern evangelical devotion to Israel relies on weak understanding of church history and history of jews and christians post Jesus, and no church authority to correct this error.

It will die with boomers.


Nails
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jew -
an ethnicity (shared characteristic). This large umbrella term is primarily defined negatively - the Nazarene is NOT the messiah. Since 70 AD. Therefore - RELIGION. NOT "RACE." I REJECT FULLY A RACIAL VIEW, AS ALL CATHOLICS MUST.
Does this mean race doesn't exist? Or there are not markers? Of course there are. That's how evolution works - self-selecting groups that isolate develop them. They exist. But BEST DEFINITION? NO.
(David Reich of Harvard, too geneticist in world, says "Jewish" goes back racially…well, not far).
LOGOS AND ANTI- … by far the best definition

Semitic and anti-Semitic
Semitic for a very long time was LINGUISTIC
To apply to "race" or to criticizing Jews …. nonsense
Wilhelm Marr (look it up) - wrong
Nazis - wrong
Many Zionists - wrong
The term should be linguistic
My Christian self is a proud Semite
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Therefore,

when Norman Lear, for 70 years one of the most prominent and consequential Jews of the 20th Century, under the influence of his newly Christian daughter, accepted Jesus Christ shortly before his death, what was he?

A Christian. Not a Jew.

When Ivanka Trump, baptized a Christian, embraced Judaism to get married, what did she formally do?

Renounce her baptism.
TeddyAg0422
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Redstone, this is great stuff
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
There are atheist Jews, including those who very strongly identified as Jewish such as Freud.

And including most of the founding mothers and fathers of the nation-state Israel, from the 1940s to now, and including Netanyahu, even as he has the prayer photo ops (it's true, look it up)

There are Buddhist Jews, oddly enough

Are there Christian Jews? … it's a very obvious contradiction in terms….and look into what the Israeli courts say about that …. maybe start with Oswald Rufeisen (book: In the Lion's Den)

Hmmm.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Can Jewish be a religion? Of course, despite the gigantic number of atheists that also claim the term.

Can Jewish be a race? The markers do exist, including for diseases.

Can Jewish be a heritage? Obviously.

But these are WEAK ways of defintion.

WHAT IS THE BEST DEFINITION.

WHAT HAS BIG EXPLANATORY POWER?

The large and diverse umbrella term "Jewish" is best unified by a DENIAL - the Nazarene is not divine, not the Messiah.

This is why Christianity is older than "Judaism" - 67 to 70, the first Roman-Jewish war, was so massively consequential that the term underwent a RADICAL RE-DEFINITION. By horrible necessity.

As a follower of Logos, a member of the people Israel like Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and so many others…..

we Christians are obligated to invite Jews to the embrace the Lord Jesus Christ, who died and rose again for all people.

There is a Temple, a Sacrifice, a priesthood, and Manna from Heaven.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Doc, lot of respect for you, and I write with affection, but such a statement is simply heresy.

Jews, fully human and fallen like all of us, have a choice, as we all do.

Any explicit rejection of Jesus Christ, which is exactly what post-70 redefined Judaism is, leads one away from the narrow gate.
one MEEN Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sapper Redux said:

one MEEN Ag said:

Sapper Redux said:

Oh good, the antisemites are feeling bold.
Hey man, everyone above my post is just spouting off low level evangelical talking points with one catholic talking about modern jewish people coming to Christ. Not exactly anti-semitiism. Dermdoc holds modern jews in higher regard than his own standing as a Christian.

You gotta wait next time til I show up before bemoaning anti-semitism. I'll go get Zobel as well.


The statement I responded to is clearly trading in antisemitic tropes. I get that as the REAL Israel you don't think you can be antisemitic, but I wasn't talking to you.


Again what were the tropes? The first page above me is just Dermdoc professing unrequited love to modern Jews and a Catholic poster saying, 'Christ will reveal himself to Jews at the end times.'

Yeah man these comments hit me like a brick thrown through a window at a New York bagel store I tell yeah. Totally the same thing.

And don't put words in my mouth. I don't believe I can not be anti-semetic because I believe the church is Israel. It's not an N-word pass where I can say terrible things because I am one.

But If you're gonna call me an anti-Semite, might as well be one. Gonna earn my street cred here. Here's a good anti-Semitic joke.



Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
When Saul made his choice, and became Paul -

he rejected EXPLICITLY the Pharisees / Sadducees / Herodian stew that was soon to emerge, from the shouldering ruins of Jerusalem, which Christ predicted, as Rabbinic / oral tradition / Talmudic "Judaism"

(Essenes and Samatarians IMO converted to Jesus en mass)

He made a choice, as we all must ….
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Let's be very specific

What is Jewish

What is Semitic

What is anti-Semitic

I've defined terms and would like to see yours
one MEEN Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BonfireNerd04 said:

one MEEN Ag said:

Sapper Redux said:

Oh good, the antisemites are feeling bold.
Hey man, everyone above my post is just spouting off low level evangelical talking points with one catholic talking about modern jewish people coming to Christ. Not exactly anti-semitiism. Dermdoc holds modern jews in higher regard than his own standing as a Christian.

You gotta wait next time til I show up before bemoaning anti-semitism. I'll go get Zobel as well.


"Synagogue of Satan" is totally an antisemitic phrase.


Here in lies the rub. Thought experiment: Can the truth be anti-Semitic?

If modern Judiasms, who cut themselves off from Christ, and have a history of Baal worship, cannot be declared under the influence of satan than what do these words satanic and anti-Semitic even mean?

If I say Hinduism is demonic and headed up by Satan-is that anti-Indian or whatever title they want? What about wiccans? Bunch of white people in the woods thinking they're worshiping benign spirits. Are they ultimately demonic and worshiping Satan even unwittingly? Is that anti-whatever?

So if I say that modern judiasms are also deceived and ultimately worship Satan either esoterically or not. Is that anti-Semitic?

When Jesus called out the Sadducees and turned over tables, was that anti-Semitic and discriminatory hate crime against Jews?

This is the problem I have with the phrase anti-Semitic. Even the most academic, plain reading of religions critique of judiasm is one offended Jew away from being labeled anti-Semitic.
Sapper Redux
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

If modern Judiasms, who cut themselves off from Christ, and have a history of Baal worship, cannot be declared under the influence of satan than what do these words satanic and anti-Semitic even mean?


History of Baal worship? Antisemitism is hatred of Jews. Claiming they are Satanic idolaters could certainly toe a fine line.
TeddyAg0422
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
And?
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Have you read the Hebrew Scriptures?
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Is this "anti-Semitic?"

Judaism is inherently Satanic.

By the Apostolic (Catholic / Orthodox) definitions I've detailed above, it is not. And, also, the statement logically follows given the assumptions of this religious commitment, by these religious definitions.

Second, and related, we MUST have definitions.

You say "hatred" of Jews is "anti-Semitic."

By the definitions I've provided, and I again ask for yours directly -

The person who would say, by their religious assumptions, that "Judaism is inherently Satanic" (me included) LOVES JEWS MORE THAN ANYBODY ELSE.

Why?

Because that which primarily, AND as the main unifying characteristic, DENIES CHRIST, is Satanic by definition.

And then to advocate for the person immersed in this to come to Christ, the Logos, the Order and Reason and Word, is to LOVE THEM.
Yukon Cornelius
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Finished the stick episode today. Will hopefully get to the next one tomorrow.

I very much enjoyed listening to it. Jesus representing both Goats of atonement, specifically the exiled one was new to me.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
With regard to Baal worship, this Catholic writer has informed speculation, with solid explanatory power - especially when one realizes that the post-70 reconstituted Judaism was VERY proselytizing until the rise of Islam.

How many know that the elites of major world crossroads power Khazaria converted en mass - as did Yemen, a major regional power, as did much of North Africa?
(And no, I do not agree with Koestler and his thesis)

https://www.unz.com/article/religious-implications-of-the-carthaginian-theory/

This thought provoking piece builds on Ron Unz, a Jewish man and amazing truth-seeker I believe will convert to Christianity. His working out of this is linked throughout, which much else there on such difficult and controversial topics, including "blood libel" …..

(By the way, the point of Ron and his site is to find truth, so a lot of controversial stuff is presented, just poke around, and I don't endorse anything except informed and honest truth-seeking, with references)
Sapper Redux
How long do you want to ignore this user?
So you're linking to a Holocaust denier spewing absolutely wild, and completely undocumented bull***** Got it.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wrong. Feel free to actually engage in detail, which sadly also didn't happen in the linked threads above.
dermdoc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Redstone said:

Doc, lot of respect for you, and I write with affection, but such a statement is simply heresy.

Jews, fully human and fallen like all of us, have a choice, as we all do.

Any explicit rejection of Jesus Christ, which is exactly what post-70 redefined Judaism is, leads one away from the narrow gate.
Lots of respect for you also. I agree with you that we have been given free will and all have a choice. As I have posted numerous times, the question is can our free will override the desire of God to save all as is clear in Scripture. I do not know that answer and can live with that tension
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
lobopride
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jesus is the True Israel. All believers in Him are part of Israel. Jesus is the Head and we are the body.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Apostolic teaching, 2,000 years old and from the Apostles, is summarized by Justin Martyr:

"Christ is king of Israel, and Christians are the Israelite race."
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Galatians 3:28
There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.

Now of course those categories exist now as they did then. Nationality is real. Race (extended family partly inbred, developed over relative isolation) is real. Various ethnic (shared characteristics) is real. Sex differences are large and real.

AND ALSO

The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob - Logos, and incarnate for us as Jesus of Nazareth - rules all, and can shatter our limitations and sins if we subjugate our will to His, embracing the telos of life as theosis to Logos. He is all over the Torah, and the very fulfillment of its promises.

We Christians are obligated to love our Jewish brethren - meaning advocating for them to come to Jesus Christ, and to cast aside the anti-Logos unifying characteristic that has defined them since Titus completely smashed Jerusalem, 67 to 70 AD, exactly as Christ predicted would happen.
one MEEN Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sapper Redux said:

Quote:

If modern Judiasms, who cut themselves off from Christ, and have a history of Baal worship, cannot be declared under the influence of satan than what do these words satanic and anti-Semitic even mean?


History of Baal worship? Antisemitism is hatred of Jews. Claiming they are Satanic idolaters could certainly toe a fine line.
Have you even read the Old Testament? Do you understand that Israel struggled so hard with worshipping Baal over YHWH that when Elijah despaired, God told Elijah there is a faithful remnant of '7000 that have never bowed to Baal' (1st Kings 19). 7000. Thats it. The whole story of Israel is that they cannot stop disobeying God and that is the faithful sliver keeping in obedience.

Do you understand how demon worship worked pre-Christ? That humans would sacrifice to these gods and receive power and wealth in this world. Demons were happy to turn sacrifices into transactions. Most of Israel was happy to be given access to the sins they wanted to partake in. Solomon himself provided a pagan prayer when dedicating the temple and then during his life put a statue of Apollo outside of it.

This is central to the story of Israel and the Messiah.

1) Christ is adamant that Israel needs a new heart that loves God, not just another teacher. They had enough teachers of the law and still couldn't turn to God. This is the holy spirit that helps humans turn to God.

2) When Christ came into this world we start to see the defanging of demon gods. Satan is fully kicked out of the presence of God through the counsel. He is cut off. Christ when he was in hades took 90% of the demons and locked them in abyss. And the idols quickly stopped working. We know this through the account of pagans saying, 'this no longer works what gives?'

3) The Baal worship never went away. A super majority of Israel never could put down the idols and walk a narrow path. They were always interested in the Baals undersell of money, sex, power over God's commands to be holy. We see a consolidation in Satan's power under his direct name starting after Christ's resurrection because the idols stop working. Its not Baal the storm God bringing crops anymore. Its Satan and demons demanding abominations directly in his name for you to get what you want. The people at the top know who they are actually dealing with. The laity might not.

4) Judiasm post Christ is slowly but surely cut off. The ribbon on the day of atonement stays red. The temple falls. The prophecies stop. The hard headed who refused to believe Christ is who he is now gets power from Satan, happy to fully jump in. This is why you see a ton of jewish overlap into mysticism and communing with spirits through kabbalism. Those are demons. 'Samuel out front shoulda told ya'

Is any of this anti-semetic? No.

Do jews like to howl at the first critique of judiasm and call it anti-semetic? Yes.

Do I hate jews? Of course not. We are called to love one another and forgive one another. I don't delight in anyone's evil though. And I don't consider condoning what I see is evil as an expression of love.

And this is the rub of anti-semitism. You can't even bring up basic issues in judiasm theology without it being anti-semetic. Nobody here is laughing about obviously anti-semetic tropes like endorsing that person who threw a brick through a bagel owner's window.
one MEEN Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yukon Cornelius said:

Finished the stick episode today. Will hopefully get to the next one tomorrow.

I very much enjoyed listening to it. Jesus representing both Goats of atonement, specifically the exiled one was new to me.
I'm excited for you. Listening to those 4 or 5 episodes was exciting. Just pure mind blowing. There's just so much beauty revealed through the orthodox understanding. It truly is the fullness of the faith.
Sapper Redux
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Redstone said:

Wrong. Feel free to actually engage in detail, which sadly also didn't happen in the linked threads above.


Buddy, the author of the piece you linked (which lacks any proof beyond a few decontextualized snippets) posts on X as "Prof Groyper" and spews blatant antisemitism. The website you linked to hosts articles by literal Neo-Nazis.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sure bud. Start another thread about Anglin if you want to argue about humorists, or about the radical leftists he also platforms.

The point here is those details about Baal, or the requests for your definitions after I've provided some detailed ones, or about any of the other questions you've been asked.

Im curious, just as I was on the other threads where you sadly declined to engage in such details and discussions.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Let me ask again, thought I'll guess you continue to ignore.

Let's be very specific. My thoughts are above.

What is Jewish?

What is Semitic?

What is anti-Semitic?

Who are the people Israel?
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Maybe you can start with your past agreement with me -

that the first Roman-Jewish war, 67 to 70 AD, was a world historical event that by grave, horrendous necessity required a massive reconstitution of the term "Jewish," given the mass slaughter and total destruction of Jerusalem, world center of its faith and practice.
Redstone
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Do you disagree that "Semitic," before Wilhelm Marr, was a term of linguistics? For many centuries? Who wishes to argue this? (My fellow Semites of Aleppo definitely thought it was linguistic)

In my opinion, Marr was wrong, Nazis were wrong, Zionists are wrong …. in the ways this term has been re-defined and weaponized. In the way it has been, very sadly, "racialized."
You?
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.