I sold every stock I own but one and went to cash

51,195 Views | 339 Replies | Last: 1 mo ago by Mr.Milkshake
knoxtom
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ensign Mayo said:

good job on selling at the right time OP. Aren't you anxious and FOMO?

Also a pretty good question.

Do I worry about missing out? Well, of course. I could absolutely be wrong. But the fear of missing out is outweighed by the fear of being right and not doing anything.

If I miss out of a big market then I make small gains and I am not quite as rich when I finally hang this up.

If I do nothing and this economy collapses then I lose a whole lot more.


Which is scarier?
knoxtom
How long do you want to ignore this user?
One more thing...

My son is 13. He has a custodial trading account (it is his college spending money account) that has lost a bunch since he loves the tech stocks. My advice to him was to just put more money in and DCA...because he has more time than me. So he just keeps buying amazon, voo, google, and Nvidia.

He is doing the right thing.

Doesn't mean I am doing the wrong thing, even though it is the exact opposite.
Proposition Joe
How long do you want to ignore this user?
knoxtom said:

3rdGenAg05 said:

Has Knoxtom said how old he/she is in here?

That is actually a really good question as it drastically affects what people should do. If I were 35 YO I wouldn't have gone to cash, I would have just bought more.

I am soon to be 57 years old and have had 2 open heart surgeries in the past year. Because of this I have become much more risk averse and don't really want to see a bunch of money go down the drain. I like the idea of making 4.5% and missing possible gains WAY more than I like the idea of losing money. While I am usually not very conservative with investments, my timing has me becoming quite cautious.

One person asked why I still hold bitcoin and honestly it is just in case the explosion occurs. The supply in bitcoin is limited so much that if every millionaire in America wanted to own a single bitcoin... there is not enough to go around. So I keep a small stack.

One other person asked why I didn't transfer the 401k immediately to bonds and waited a few weeks. I have no real reason. I have always just been taught to never touch the 401k and sometimes it is hard to go against what you were taught.

I think those are all very reasonable reasons/takes.

I don't know your situation, but I think you might be nearing the point where the upside of the market simply isn't worth the downside. Your net worth increasing another 40% over the next 10 years would be great, but it probably isn't going to impact what you are doing with your life too much. But if it decreases 40% it certainly changes things.

That's a tough thing for some people to wrap their minds around because "the math" says doing something will make the account grow bigger... but the actual reasons you have the account don't revolve around math, they revolve around your quality of life.

Again, I don't know your net worth or what your future plans are -- but I've seen a lot of people who struggle to understand they've "won" the game and playing the higher stakes of the market (compared to bonds, etc...) simply doesn't make sense anymore.

But I think most of the pushback you see from posters is because you decided to start your own thread about it
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Proposition Joe said:

knoxtom said:

3rdGenAg05 said:

Has Knoxtom said how old he/she is in here?

That is actually a really good question as it drastically affects what people should do. If I were 35 YO I wouldn't have gone to cash, I would have just bought more.

I am soon to be 57 years old and have had 2 open heart surgeries in the past year. Because of this I have become much more risk averse and don't really want to see a bunch of money go down the drain. I like the idea of making 4.5% and missing possible gains WAY more than I like the idea of losing money. While I am usually not very conservative with investments, my timing has me becoming quite cautious.

One person asked why I still hold bitcoin and honestly it is just in case the explosion occurs. The supply in bitcoin is limited so much that if every millionaire in America wanted to own a single bitcoin... there is not enough to go around. So I keep a small stack.

One other person asked why I didn't transfer the 401k immediately to bonds and waited a few weeks. I have no real reason. I have always just been taught to never touch the 401k and sometimes it is hard to go against what you were taught.

I think those are all very reasonable reasons/takes.

I don't know your situation, but I think you might be nearing the point where the upside of the market simply isn't worth the downside. Your net worth increasing another 40% over the next 10 years would be great, but it probably isn't going to impact what you are doing with your life too much. But if it decreases 40% it certainly changes things.

That's a tough thing for some people to wrap their minds around because "the math" says doing something will make the account grow bigger... but the actual reasons you have the account don't revolve around math, they revolve around your quality of life.

Again, I don't know your net worth or what your future plans are -- but I've seen a lot of people who struggle to understand they've "won" the game and playing the higher stakes of the market (compared to bonds, etc...) simply doesn't make sense anymore.

But I think most of the pushback you see from posters is because you decided to start your own thread about it


Totally agree. Now that we know he is 57 this makes much more sense (although going 100% cash still makes me itch a little).

I'm 51 and de-risked back in December. Kind of wished I had de-risked even more.

Your statement in bold is the exact thing I told my FA when I made that decision and he wholeheartedly agreed.
bmoochie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Great post. I personally don't think knowing your age matters because everyone has a different strategy or risk tolerance. So people on here bashing you just don't like your strategy and nothing more. They clearly have a higher risk tolerance which is fine. I personally do as well as I'm 35.

EliteZags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
personally I'm among those that feel more pain from missing out on gains than seeing losses, probably because historically every loss eventually has eventually recovered but a lot of the missed gains will never have another chance to get back
JR2007
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
EliteZags said:

personally I'm among those that feel more pain from missing out on gains than seeing losses, probably because historically every loss eventually has eventually recovered but a lot of the missed gains will never have another chance to get back


Same. I share this chart with my peers with a long investment horizon when they get uneasy with the markets. https://www.visualcapitalist.com/chart-timing-the-market/
jamey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
knoxtom said:

One more thing...

My son is 13. He has a custodial trading account (it is his college spending money account) that has lost a bunch since he loves the tech stocks. My advice to him was to just put more money in and DCA...because he has more time than me. So he just keeps buying amazon, voo, google, and Nvidia.

He is doing the right thing.

Doesn't mean I am doing the wrong thing, even though it is the exact opposite.



Guess it depends on whether you think the mag 7 will continue to represent 30% or more of the S&P, or not.
wessimo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Update - S&P 500

2/27/25 - 5862
5/12/25 - 5844 (updated at market close)

Ensign Mayo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
OP might have missed the boat!
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Poor OP.
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Proposition Joe said:

knoxtom said:

3rdGenAg05 said:

Has Knoxtom said how old he/she is in here?

That is actually a really good question as it drastically affects what people should do. If I were 35 YO I wouldn't have gone to cash, I would have just bought more.

I am soon to be 57 years old and have had 2 open heart surgeries in the past year. Because of this I have become much more risk averse and don't really want to see a bunch of money go down the drain. I like the idea of making 4.5% and missing possible gains WAY more than I like the idea of losing money. While I am usually not very conservative with investments, my timing has me becoming quite cautious.

One person asked why I still hold bitcoin and honestly it is just in case the explosion occurs. The supply in bitcoin is limited so much that if every millionaire in America wanted to own a single bitcoin... there is not enough to go around. So I keep a small stack.

One other person asked why I didn't transfer the 401k immediately to bonds and waited a few weeks. I have no real reason. I have always just been taught to never touch the 401k and sometimes it is hard to go against what you were taught.

I think those are all very reasonable reasons/takes.

I don't know your situation, but I think you might be nearing the point where the upside of the market simply isn't worth the downside. Your net worth increasing another 40% over the next 10 years would be great, but it probably isn't going to impact what you are doing with your life too much. But if it decreases 40% it certainly changes things.

That's a tough thing for some people to wrap their minds around because "the math" says doing something will make the account grow bigger... but the actual reasons you have the account don't revolve around math, they revolve around your quality of life.

Again, I don't know your net worth or what your future plans are -- but I've seen a lot of people who struggle to understand they've "won" the game and playing the higher stakes of the market (compared to bonds, etc...) simply doesn't make sense anymore.

But I think most of the pushback you see from posters is because you decided to start your own thread about it


Totally agree. Now that we know he is 57 this makes much more sense (although going 100% cash still makes me itch a little).

I'm 51 and de-risked back in December. Kind of wished I had de-risked even more.

Your statement in bold is the exact thing I told my FA when I made that decision and he wholeheartedly agreed.

What did you do to "de-risk"?
bmoochie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He clearly outlined his plan and his age factors into wanting to be less risk on. Quit being a *****
I Am A Critic
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bmoochie said:

He clearly outlined his plan and his age factors into wanting to be less risk on. Quit being a *****
You've got your posters confused. He was asking YouBet what he did to de-risk. Quit being a *****.
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bmoochie said:

He clearly outlined his plan and his age factors into wanting to be less risk on. Quit being a *****

Another internet bully. Go pick on someone who is scared of you.

Going all cash is a dumb idea unless one is 100 years old.

Gnome Sayin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
i'm back in the positive after today after the tariff drop off. Thank you Biden/harris!!!!
DannyDuberstein
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So difficult to time. And the world is full of change and instability. If I sat out because of that, I'd have never earned. I just fall back on my "here's what I need in the next 5 years and therefore should be more conservative" and "here's what I can let ride in the market", which I'm 51 now and 4-5 years from retiring so it's essentially all the latter. I'll start rolling some non-taxable to more conservative as I go over the next 5 to line up with that approach. And thankfully, I do have a nice pension that is my stability anchor.
TxAG#2011
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Terrible position to be in. You owe a huge tax bill but now FOMO sets in and you are chasing higher.

You buy back in and the market starts to **** and you see your balance evaporating. Oh, you still owe that huge tax bill.

Happened to me one year trading Ethereum for Solana at the top. Won't make that mistake again.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
infinity ag said:



What did you do to "de-risk"?
Re-allocated from 85% equities / 15% fixed income to 75/25.

Will likely ratchet that down further over this year and lock more in because I have a retirement tollgate decision in 2027.
tlh3842
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
infinity ag said:

Poor OP.


He never once bragged about being right as all of us were sweating the last month. Didn't hop on every thread bragging as well fell, but people sure run here once it's back to basically flat.
OP was able to time some of the biggest drops in history. Make no mistake, the Rollercoaster of Trump and tariffs isn't over yet. With all that said, he pretty much timed the market to avoid some pretty big drops.
JP76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bmoochie said:

He clearly outlined his plan and his age factors into wanting to be less risk on. Quit being a *****



How does buying bitcoin fit into his risk aversion ?
Aglaw97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Some people are WAY too obsessed with the investing decisions of another person. If you are comfortable with your philosophy who cares what someone else does and why?
Yukon Cornelius
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jealousy that they sold. Some people can't. But it's equally strange the OP had to come here to talk about it. Looking to brag or for social validation? This entire thread is interesting.
EliteZags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
in the past few month's firesale I unfortunately was only able to deploy ~60-70% of sidelined cash which was not a large portfolio percentage to start with, but looking back at some of the deals I was able to get:

PLTR $70-75
HOOD $30-35
AMD $75-80
NVDA $85-90
SOFI $9.50-10
AMZN $160-170
PATH $9.50-10
AVGO $150
and the recent GOOG dip to $150


so combine OP's exit timing with my dip buying then we'd be cooking
DannyDuberstein
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
tlh3842 said:

infinity ag said:

Poor OP.


He never once bragged about being right as all of us were sweating the last month. Didn't hop on every thread bragging as well fell, but people sure run here once it's back to basically flat.
OP was able to time some of the biggest drops in history. Make no mistake, the Rollercoaster of Trump and tariffs isn't over yet. With all that said, he pretty much timed the market to avoid some pretty big drops.


Without knowing the tax impact, there is no way to evaluate what he actually avoided. If he hasn't jumped back in, any tax impact likely puts him underwater vs those who held (as of right now)
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I study all the retirement planning podcasts and most disagree with you.

if you are 51- you could have THIRTY MORE YEARS ahead of you in which you need funds.

unless you are already a multi-millionaire and want to just live a middle class existence

you will need to stay aggressive to a certain extent.
GoAgs92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Poor OP?

Poor me, I am still down $35K.

txaggie_08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
There's nothing wrong with him being 75% equities, 25% bonds/fixed income at his age.
I bleed maroon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
LMCane said:

I study all the retirement planning podcasts and most disagree with you.
You see, that is the difference between a bot and a person. There is pseudo-knowledge which is second-hand, and then there's actual experience.

Bottom line: There is no one better to assess personal risk tolerance than the person themselves. They may make decisions we disagree with, but we don't have the complete picture like they do. There isn't a right and wrong, so the best we can do is provide different perspectives to help them analyze their situation.

I'm still in the camp of believing the OP did the right thing for him at the time, even though I do not concur with his train of thought.
jamey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
EliteZags said:

in the past few month's firesale I unfortunately was only able to deploy ~60-70% of sidelined cash which was not a large portfolio percentage to start with, but looking back at some of the deals I was able to get:

PLTR $70-75
HOOD $30-35
AMD $75-80
NVDA $85-90
SOFI $9.50-10
AMZN $160-170
PATH $9.50-10
AVGO $150
and the recent GOOG dip to $150


so combine OP's exit timing with my dip buying then we'd be cooking



My main get is an often overlooked AI play

ARKG as low as $18, now at $22 with a lot of room to go long term

XBI as low as $69, now at $78 with aot of room to go long term
wessimo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
wessimo said:

Update - S&P 500

2/27/25 - 5862
5/12/25 - 5844 (updated at market close)




5/13/25 - 5891
aggieiniowa
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Congrats on finding what makes you comfortable and able to sleep at night. Making 4.5% and sleeping well is way better than having money in the market and feeling uneasy about it.

For me we are in full investment aggressive mode and will be for a while. It sucks when the market drops, but a financial advisor told me once that was great for me because I could just keep buying low. Being comfortable in your decision outweighs whether someone assumes you made the right or wrong decision.
Proposition Joe
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I think there's a case to be made both ways.

If you're sitting on $20M at age 50, and aren't interested in owning yachts and jets, then having a lot of money in the market outside of fixed investment vehicles is simply not smart.

At $2M it's a completely different story.

So, don't knock people's decisions as they all have different situations... that being said, to take the time to create a new topic signaling the move to cash instead of posting in the main thread wanted attention, so the potshots are fair.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
LMCane said:

I study all the retirement planning podcasts and most disagree with you.

if you are 51- you could have THIRTY MORE YEARS ahead of you in which you need funds.

unless you are already a multi-millionaire and want to just live a middle class existence

you will need to stay aggressive to a certain extent.
All of our Monte Carlo sims and other modeling showing us to be fine well into our 90s. Barring the catastrophic failure of the US (which could happen and in which case all bets are off and we are all equally screwed) we are locking in now to hit those models.

As someone else said, we aren't looking to buy a yacht and exotic stuff so really just want to "insure" our day to day life as much as we can knowing the world (IMO) is going to be much more volatile going forward. We have both mostly moved on from accumulating stuff at this point so just wanting money to live, travel, and pay for healthcare.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
YouBet said:

LMCane said:

I study all the retirement planning podcasts and most disagree with you.

if you are 51- you could have THIRTY MORE YEARS ahead of you in which you need funds.

unless you are already a multi-millionaire and want to just live a middle class existence

you will need to stay aggressive to a certain extent.
All of our Monte Carlo sims and other modeling showing us to be fine well into our 90s. Barring the catastrophic failure of the US (which could happen and in which case all bets are off and we are all equally screwed) we are locking in now to hit those models.

As someone else said, we aren't looking to buy a yacht and exotic stuff so really just want to "insure" our day to day life as much as we can knowing the world (IMO) is going to be much more volatile going forward. We have both mostly moved on from accumulating stuff at this point so just wanting money to live, travel, and pay for healthcare.
I do reserve the right to buy overly expensive watches that are on my wish list.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.