PebbleTec PebbleSheen line or Stonscapes Mini line:

Thoughts and feedback about either? Or am I missing something?

TIA

PebbleTec was the 1st generation of this new finish type. It was pretty rough on feet so the came out with PebbleSheen. I got PebbleSheen 2 years ago and love.

We moved recently and our previous pool was PebbleTec. Our new pool is gunnite. I don't think we go a week without one of the kids saying how happy they are to not have our old pool because it hurt their feet so bad.

Right-O; yes, The Original PebbleTec line is not an option I am pursuing. Either the PebbleSheen line, or another PebbleTec line, or Stonecapes Mini line, or something else.

Ah my bad, my brain translated a comma into your original post for 3 options and not the two. Carry on

First pool had Stonescapes Mini and this one has Pebblesheen. They've performed identical for me. Your installer is the biggest variable so just stay on them.

No issues with feet

I build pools and I have installed both.

I personally think PebbleTec uses a higher quality stone than NPT (Stonescapes) does and the finish ends up a bit smoother.

Another thing to think about is anyone can buy NPT plaster products from the supply house but you have to be a registered PebbleTec vendor to buy their products from them. This means that they've seen your installs and trust you to sell & install their products to a certain level of competency.

Pretty sure PebbleTech has a PebbleFina line which is really smooth. I had PebbleSheen and loved it.

I just looked at the contract from our 2019 build. I was surprised to see it was Stonescapes that was used.

Zero problems so far. Gold Medal was the builder and they've built a lot of pools. I have no idea if they use it still or switched.

cevans_40 said:

---

Pretty sure PebbleTech has a PebbleFina line which is really smooth. I had PebbleSheen and loved it.

---

Yes, PebbleFina much smoother as I understand, but obviously comes at an additional cost. The value proposition to spring for that cost is not there as this is 70,000+ gallon pool. CorpsAg might have some additional commentary about PebbleFina…?

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

I build pools and I have installed both.

I personally think PebbleTec uses a higher quality stone than NPT (Stonescapes) does and the finish ends up a bit smoother.

Another thing to think about is anyone can buy NPT plaster products from the supply house but you have to be a registered PebbleTec vendor to buy their products from them. This means that they've seen your installs and trust you to sell & install their products to a certain level of competency.

---

This is the feedback I am here for.
The last pool I built at our last development, we used PebbleSheen Blue Granite. I was wondering if any one had anything burning to say to sway me into another direction. I do like how PebbleTec is a proprietary product which comes with a corresponding check on the vendor and installer side of things, which is good. However, if you trust and know your installer, does the StoneScapes Mini line offer nearly the same performance, look, and feel from a value standpoint? It seems like if you remove the installer variable from the equation, StoneScapes Mini line is an enticing option.

We just had our 11 year old pool redone with PebbleFina Classico. Literally finished Wednesday. Yesterday was first swim. We think it's Awesome! Took 3 days of manual labor, one day to fill back up and we're still adjusting chemicals. Pool looks/feels brand new!

For those who have resurfaced, if you don't mind, could you please share a ball park of how much that cost?

I bought a house with an existing pool and know that will be coming my way. Just trying to be prepared. I think our pool is only like 14,000 gallons

I would say your savings for stonescapes vs pebblesheen should be in the $750-1500 range, at least my pricing would be. Obviously that's a guess cause I don't know the size of your pool or the depth or if you have a spa.

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

I would say your savings for stonescapes vs pebblesheen should be in the $750-1500 range, at least my pricing would be. Obviously that's a guess cause I don't know the size of your pool or the depth or if you have a spa.

---

70,000+ gallons

2 Sun shelfs at each end, going to 3-6 to 5 to 3-6

What area do you build pools in?

I'd go with a pebble Tec product over NPT every time

Pebble sheen is excellent
Pebble breeze has been amazing for our clients so far, but can be pricey

Feel free to DM me if you'd like. We've been using pebble Tec products since 2002 and have an excellent relationship with them

Your location would be helpful as the quality of the installer is obviously a huge component

Gig em!

MS08 said:

---

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

I would say your savings for stonescapes vs pebblesheen should be in the $750-1500 range, at least my pricing would be. Obviously that's a guess cause I don't know the size of your pool or the depth or if you have a spa.

---

70,000+ gallons

2 Sun shelfs at each end, going to 3-6 to 5 to 3-6

What area do you build pools in?

---

Gallons doesn't do anything for me unfortunately. I'd need your depth plus perimeter. Over 125 LF perimeter it switches to interior surface area. At least that's how we measure up in DFW.

I'm in west Fort Worth, but we build in Tarrant & Park County. I've done a few further north, west, and south of those areas. Avoid anything east of 360 like the plague if I can help it.

Love the pebble sheen in my pool. Great texture and look.

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

MS08 said:

---

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

I would say your savings for stonescapes vs pebblesheen should be in the $750-1500 range, at least my pricing would be. Obviously that's a guess cause I don't know the size of your pool or the depth or if you have a spa.

---

70,000+ gallons

2 Sun shelfs at each end, going to 3-6 to 5 to 3-6

What area do you build pools in?

---

Gallons doesn't do anything for me unfortunately. I'd need your depth plus perimeter. Over 125 LF perimeter it switches to interior surface area. At least that's how we measure up in DFW.

I'm in west Fort Worth, but we build in Tarrant & Park County. I've done a few further north, west, and south of those areas. Avoid anything east of 360 like the plague if I can help it.

---

Gotcha. Rectangle as can be. 30' wide and 80' long. 220 total Linear Feet. 2400 Sqft.

poolct00 said:

---

I'd go with a pebble Tec product over NPT every time

Pebble sheen is excellent
Pebble breeze has been amazing for our clients so far, but can be pricey

Feel free to DM me if you'd like. We've been using pebble Tec products since 2002 and have an excellent relationship with them

Your location would be helpful as the quality of the installer is obviously a huge component

Gig em!

---

Thanks for the advice. PebbleSheen is how I was always leaning. I'm looking to have this pool built in College Station.

I would consider the PebbleFina or PebbleBreeze line for the custom home I intend to build. But, what is the difference between those two lines?

MS08 said:

---

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

MS08 said:

---

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

I would say your savings for stonescapes vs pebblesheen should be in the $750-1500 range, at least my pricing would be. Obviously that's a guess cause I don't know the size of your pool or the depth or if you have a spa.

---

70,000+ gallons

2 Sun shelfs at each end, going to 3-6 to 5 to 3-6

What area do you build pools in?

---

Gallons doesn't do anything for me unfortunately. I'd need your depth plus perimeter. Over 125 LF perimeter it switches to interior surface area. At least that's how we measure up in DFW.

I'm in west Fort Worth, but we build in Tarrant & Park County. I've done a few further north, west, and south of those areas. Avoid anything east of 360 like the plague if I can help it.

---

Gotcha. Rectangle as can be. 30' wide and 80' long. 220 total Linear Feet. 2400 Sqft.

---

Damn dude let's see some pics of that bad boy

lotsofhp said:

---

MS08 said:

---

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

MS08 said:

---

Corps_Ag12 said:

---

I would say your savings for stonescapes vs pebblesheen should be in the $750-1500 range, at least my pricing would be. Obviously that's a guess cause I don't know the size of your pool or the depth or if you have a spa.

---

70,000+ gallons

2 Sun shelfs at each end, going to 3-6 to 5 to 3-6

What area do you build pools in?

---

Gallons doesn't do anything for me unfortunately. I'd need your depth plus perimeter. Over 125 LF perimeter it switches to interior surface area. At least that's how we measure up in DFW.

I'm in west Fort Worth, but we build in Tarrant & Park County. I've done a few further north, west, and south of those areas. Avoid anything east of 360 like the plague if I can help it.

---

Gotcha. Rectangle as can be. 30' wide and 80' long. 220 total Linear Feet. 2400 Sqft.

---

Damn dude let's see some pics of that bad boy

---

Yes, can post pics of the project. Note, not for personal residence; for the townhome community I am developing. Pool and surrounding landscaping will be a lush though!