The thing I keep coming back to is more macro than the pairings decisions, roster bubble selections, Scottie's struggles, course setup, etc.
The Euros have better infrastructure in place to be on the cutting edge of strategic shifts than we do. They have better leadership, continuity, and all-around buy-in to their processes. It trickles down.
I was thinking earlier about how Team USA Ryder Cup needs its version of Team USA basketball in 2006. Modernize the team infrastructure and make it more cohesive. Then I realized we kind of already had that with the task force following the 2014 Ryder Cup.
The task force served us well in combatting some of the Euros' longer term edges.
- They were always more close / had more comradery. We've done work since then to bring our teams closer together. Even though we might not be as "familial" as the Euros, I think our guys have closer bonds than they did back in the Tiger/Phil era.
- They knew how to setup their home courses to manufacture advantages. We did that well in 2016 and 2021.
After 2021, I think the Euros pushed the envelope and took the strategic and personnel dynamics of the tournament to another level.
- They recognized that traditional course setup advantages no longer applied and they had to be more nuanced in seeking out advantages. We did not do that this year.
- Their players, led by Rory, made it their personal mission to treat the Ryder Cup like their most important event of the year and catered their games/schedules to play their best. We've made some small steps in that direction but obviously no where near them.
I think the first bullet above could be neutralized by a Task Force 2.0 of sorts. But then what? We do the same things another couple years until the Euros move the goal post again? Then we react after another home beatdown, when it's too late? This macro trend is more important than captain selection IMO. I really hope we see some sort of evidence that we're going to start taking the "behind the scenes" aspect of the tournament seriously, but I'll believe it when I see it.
Likewise with the players, I'll believe they're willing to treat the Cup as seriously as the Euros when Scottie puts his neck out there and makes it his personal mission, like Rory did. If he does, I think the rest will follow. I don't think it's going to happen but you never know. And I don't mean that to say our guys don't care. I think they do to a very large extent. Just not as much as the Euros.